Redesigned Your Website and Lost Your Rankings? Here’s What Broke
Episode summary
You launch the new website, it looks great, and three weeks later the phone is quieter and your own services have slipped down the page. Steve explains that this usually isn’t bad luck and usually isn’t Google punishing you. A redesign changes things Google was relying on, and almost nobody checks them on launch day. He also shares a client story where a redesign by another company, without proper redirects, led to a ranking dip and a lost client.
The episode explains how to tell whether your drop is normal (an established site will often dip for 60 to 90 days even with redirects done right) and walks through the five things that break most often: old page addresses with no redirects, the site telling Google to stay away, ranking words cut from key pages, outside links pointing at dead addresses, and local business details that didn’t make the move. Each comes with a check you can run in minutes.
It closes with how The Branding Agency handles a redesign, including a redirect map, a top-20-page content check, and one person who owns rankings at launch, and with what to do if the drop has already happened. It’s for owners planning a redesign or recovering from one.
Key takeaways
- Some ranking movement after a redesign is normal. Google says to expect temporary fluctuation, and an established site with strong rankings will often dip 60 to 90 days even when redirects are done right.
- Before you panic, confirm the drop is real: analytics tracking is often lost in a redesign, so check Google Search Console performance, which comes from Google Search itself.
- Break 1: old page addresses. Use Search Console’s pages report to find not found (404) URLs and add a 301 redirect from each old address to the matching new page, kept in place for at least a year. Don’t send every old page to the homepage.
- Break 2: the site telling Google to stay away. In WordPress, make sure “Discourage search engines from indexing this site” is unticked under Settings, Reading, and check noindex tags and robots.txt.
- Break 3: cut ranking words. Export your top 20 pages and their queries before the redesign, and confirm after launch that the key phrases, page titles, FAQs and towns-served text are still there.
- Break 4: outside links. Tap the website button on your Google Business Profile and check Search Console’s links report for old addresses that need redirects.
- Break 5: local details. Compare the new footer word for word against your Google Business Profile and run the homepage through Google’s rich results test, because a redesign can also make you disappear from AI answers.
- If it already happened, fix what you find, request indexing in Search Console and resubmit your sitemap. Recovery isn’t instant and can take a couple of months.
In this episode
- 00:00 The Redesign That Quietly Cost You Rankings
- 00:16 A Redesign Gone Wrong: The Client Story
- 01:06 What You’ll Learn in This Episode
- 01:21 Is Your Drop Normal? Timing After a Redesign
- 02:09 Check the Drop Is Real: Search Console vs. Analytics
- 02:25 Break 1: Your Old Page Addresses Are Gone
- 03:12 The 301 Redirect Fix
- 03:29 The Trap: Sending Everything to the Homepage
- 04:19 Break 2: The Site Is Telling Google to Stay Away
- 05:23 Break 3: The Words That Ranked Got Cut
- 06:43 Classic Home Billiards: Ranking Page by Page
- 06:58 Break 4: The Internet Still Points at Your Old Site
- 07:31 Break 5: The Local Details Didn’t Make the Move
- 08:18 How a Redesign Affects AI Search
- 09:09 How We Handle a Redesign
- 09:42 3 Checks You Can Do Today
- 10:13 Free Checklist and Next Steps
- 11:17 Get Your AI Visibility Score
Related from The Branding Agency
Read the full transcript
You launched the new website. It looks great. Everybody says so. Then three weeks later the phone’s a little quieter, and when you search for your own services, you’ve slipped down the page or you’re gone. That isn’t bad luck, and it usually isn’t Google punishing you. A redesign changes things Google was relying on, and almost nobody checks them on launch day.
I’ve lived this one. We had an SEO client whose website was already performing really well. They decided to have another company redesign it. Before they started, I asked them, “Your site is doing great. Why risk it?” They went ahead anyway. The developer had no idea how to handle redirects, so we spent a huge amount of time mapping them ourselves before launch. The site still dipped, and when rankings drop after a redesign, guess who gets the blame? Not the developer. We lost that client. So this is the conversation I wish every business owner heard before a redesign.
At The Branding Agency, we build websites, we do traditional SEO, and we do AI search optimization, all in-house. So we see redesigns from every side. In this episode: how to tell if your drop is normal, the five things that break most often, and how to check each one in minutes. And at the end, I’ll show you exactly how we handle a redesign so this doesn’t happen. I’m Steve.
First, timing. Google says to expect temporary ranking fluctuation when a site moves, and that it can take a few weeks or more for the new pages to settle in. In my experience, an older site with strong rankings will almost always dip for 60 to 90 days, even when the redirects are done right. So a dip by itself isn’t the problem. A drop that keeps getting worse, or pages that vanish completely, usually means one of five things broke.
Before you panic, check that the drop is real. Many redesigns quietly lose the analytics tracking code. Traffic in your analytics falls off a cliff on launch day, and it looks like your rankings died. Open Google Search Console instead and look at performance. That data comes from Google Search itself, not from a tag on your site. If clicks there are steady, your rankings are fine. Your tracking is what broke.
Break number one: your old page addresses are gone. A new site usually means new addresses. Your AC repair page used to live at /services/ac-repair. Now it’s /ac-repair. To you, it’s the same page. To Google, the address it ranked doesn’t exist anymore. Every ranking you built was attached to that old address. Here’s the check: in Search Console, open the pages report and look for “Not found (404).” Those are old addresses people and Google are still trying to reach. The fix is a permanent redirect, a 301, from each old address to the new page that matches it. Keep those redirects in place. Google generally says at least a year. Then update your own menus and buttons that still point to old addresses. That check is on the free checklist, first link in the description.
Now, the trap. A developer who doesn’t know redirects will often take a shortcut and send every old page to the homepage. Google’s own instructions say don’t do that. It confuses people, and Google may treat it as a soft 404, which basically means the old page counts as gone anyway. Your water heater page should point to your new water heater page, not your home page. This is exactly why, when we rebuild a website, the redirect map is part of the build. Every old address gets matched to its new page before launch day, not after the phone goes quiet. Most developers treat that as somebody else’s job. We don’t, because we’re the ones who answer for the rankings. If you’re planning a redesign, that’s the third link in the description.
Break number two: the site is telling Google to stay away. Most new sites get built on a test copy with a setting switched on to keep search engines out while it’s unfinished. Then launch day comes and nobody turns it off. In WordPress, that box is called “Discourage search engines from indexing this site.” Tick it, and every page carries the tag that says “don’t index me.” This one takes 30 seconds. In WordPress, go to Settings, then Reading, and make sure that box is unticked. Then in Search Console, paste your home page into URL inspection and check that Google can index it. If you’re not on WordPress, ask your developer two questions: is anything on the site set to noindex, and is anything blocked in a file called robots.txt? Google’s own site move checklist warns about both, and yes, they’re on our checklist, too.
Break number three: the words that ranked got cut. Redesigns are sold on looks, so the long service page that was ranking gets trimmed down to three bullet points and a big photo because the old one looked cluttered. But Google doesn’t rank the photo. It ranks the words that answered what people were searching for. Before any redesign, export your top 20 pages from Search Console along with the searches each one shows up for. After launch, open each new page and check that those words are still there. If your best page ranked for “water heater replacement in Matthews,” that phrase had better still be on it. Check the page titles, too. A new theme can turn “AC repair in Huntersville” into just “Services.” And watch the FAQs and the towns-you-serve paragraph. They’re often the first things cut, and often why the page ranked. The before and after steps are on the free checklist.
This is the traditional SEO side of what we do. Take our client Classic Home Billiards, with showrooms in Charlotte and Charleston. Their site ranks in Google’s top three for more than 50 searches, page by page, because every page answers a real search. That’s not a design feature. It’s the words. And it’s exactly what a redesign can wipe out in an afternoon.
Break number four: the rest of the internet still points at your old site. Your Google Business Profile has a website link, maybe an appointment link. Your directory listings have links. Other websites link to specific pages. If those old pages now hit an error, every one of those links is a dead end, including the one customers just tap on the map. Your check: pull out your phone, find your business on Google Maps, and tap the website button. Does it land on a real page? Then in Search Console, open Links and look at your top linked pages. Any old address on that list needs a redirect. For your most important links, ask the site owner to update them.
Break number five: the local details didn’t make the move. The old site had your name, address, and phone number in the footer, a map, and the code that tells Google you’re a local business. A new theme doesn’t carry any of that over automatically. We covered why those matter in our 47-website audit episode. The redesign question is simpler: did they survive? Compare your new footer word for word against your Google Business Profile, and run the homepage through Google’s rich results test. Both steps are on the checklist.
And here’s the part most people miss. A redesign doesn’t just affect Google. ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google’s AI answers read your site, too. Lose those details, and you can disappear from AI answers right along with your rankings. Get them right, and the redesign becomes your chance to show up there. That’s the AI search side of our work. AI tools now cite Classic Home Billiards more than 400 times across six different platforms. Ask ChatGPT if it would recommend them, and the first word of the answer is “yes.” If you want to know where you stand in AI search right now, before or after a redesign, that’s the second link in the description.
So here’s how we handle a redesign, and it’s what you should demand from anyone who touches your site. Before anyone starts, every current page address gets listed with where it will redirect. Your top 20 pages keep the content that ranks them. On launch day, search engines get turned back on, and we tap every link that matters, starting with your Google Business Profile. And one person owns the rankings at launch. That’s the one I learned the hard way. If your developer won’t own the redirects, find out now, not after the drop.
If it already happened, fix what you find, request indexing in Search Console, and resubmit your sitemap. Recovery isn’t instant. On an established site, that dip can last a couple of months. Three checks you can do today: tap the website link on your Google Business Profile, check the “discourage search engines” box, and look at the Not found list in Search Console.
Now, I know 99% of you are going to listen to this, grab the free checklist in the first link, fix it yourself, and never work with us. And that’s completely fine. Every check from this episode, plus that redesign plan, is on it. We give the information away for free. We charge for doing the work. But maybe 1% of you want it done for you: a redesign that keeps your rankings, SEO that grows them, or AI search optimization that gets you recommended. One team, all in-house, nothing outsourced. That’s the third link. Use the video code REDESIGN. On the first call, we look at where you are now, where you want to be, and whether we’re a good fit. We work best with established local businesses whose website already brings in calls, owners about to redesign who don’t want to gamble their rankings, and businesses that already took the hit.
And if you’re not ready for that but want to know exactly where you stand, the second link gets you our AI Visibility Score: a score from 0 to 100, the real AI answers for your services and towns, and who’s showing up ahead of you. It’s $100, credited in full toward your first month if you hire us. Redesigned yet? Listen to our 47-website audit episode next, so your redesign fixes those five mistakes, too. And tell me in the comments: have you redesigned your website and watched your rankings drop? How long ago? I’m Steve with The Branding Agency, and I’ll see you in the next one.
Want help ranking in Charlotte?
The Branding Agency builds local and AI-search visibility for small businesses. Book a free consultation.
Get your free consultation